TMS vs. Spravato: Which Depression Treatment Fits You?

On this page ▾
- TMS vs. Spravato: An Overview
- How TMS Works
- How Spravato Works
- TMS vs. Spravato: Side-by-Side Comparison
- Who May Be a Better Fit for TMS?
- Who May Be a Better Fit for Spravato?
- Can You Combine TMS and Spravato?
- How to Decide: Questions to Ask Your Provider
- Spravato Care at Marpa Minds
- Frequently Asked Questions
Key takeaways
- A coil placed against your scalp sends magnetic pulses to a brain area involved in mood.
- Spravato is a nasal spray made from esketamine.
- Spravato can work within hours to days for some patients.
- TMS means shorter visits but many of them, every weekday.
- Moving to the other is a common next step, since they work through different mechanisms.
TMS vs Spravato is a common question once a few antidepressants haven’t worked. Both treat depression through a different route than a daily pill, and both can be covered by insurance. They differ a lot in how they feel, how much time they take, and who they suit best.
TMS vs. Spravato: An Overview
Time commitment
TMS
20–36 sessions
Most courses run five days a week for four to six weeks, about 20 to 36 sessions.
Spravato®
2 a week, then weekly
Treatment starts at two sessions a week for the first month.
Two FDA-Approved Options for Treatment-Resistant Depression
TMS is FDA-cleared and Spravato is FDA-approved, both for depression that hasn’t responded to standard antidepressants. Neither one is a first step. They come into the picture after medication has fallen short.
Why Patients Compare Them
On paper they look similar. In practice, one means daily visits and no side effects you’d feel in the room. The other means fewer visits but a monitored session. That trade-off drives most of the decision.
How TMS Works
Magnetic Pulses and Targeted Brain Regions
A coil placed against your scalp sends magnetic pulses to a brain area involved in mood. You stay awake. There’s no medication and no sedation.
What a Typical TMS Course Looks Like
Most courses run five days a week for four to six weeks, about 20 to 36 sessions. Each one lasts roughly 20 to 40 minutes. You can drive yourself and go back to your day.
A TMS course, in numbers
Most courses run five days a week for four to six weeks
Each one lasts roughly 20 to 40 minutes.
Common Side Effects of TMS

The usual ones are mild scalp discomfort and a headache that fades within hours. Seizure is rare. Our guide to TMS therapy covers safety and who should avoid it.
How Spravato Works
Targeting NMDA Receptors Instead of Serotonin
Spravato is a nasal spray made from esketamine. It blocks NMDA receptors and raises activity in the brain’s glutamate system, which is a different path than SSRIs take.
The Induction and Maintenance Schedule

Treatment starts at two sessions a week for the first month. After that it moves to weekly, then to a schedule based on how you respond. Each session takes about two hours.
Common Side Effects and Why Monitoring Matters
Dissociation, dizziness, nausea, and a temporary rise in blood pressure are the most common effects. They usually pass within the monitoring window. A provider stays with you for at least two hours after every dose, and you can’t drive home.
Want the science behind each approach? Read the science →
TMS vs. Spravato: Side-by-Side Comparison
Speed of Relief
Spravato can work within hours to days for some patients. TMS usually takes three to four weeks of daily sessions before a change shows up.
Effectiveness and Response Rates
Reviews of TMS research put response rates around 40 to 50 percent, with remission near 25 to 30 percent. In a 2023 trial, about 27 percent of patients on Spravato plus an antidepressant reached remission by eight weeks, rising to nearly half by 32 weeks. These come from different studies, so they can’t be compared head to head.
Time Commitment and Session Length
TMS means shorter visits but many of them, every weekday. Spravato means fewer visits that each take about two hours.
Side Effects and Safety Considerations
TMS has milder, shorter-lived effects. Spravato has stronger effects in the room, which is why it requires supervision.
Insurance Coverage and Cost
Both are covered by most major plans and Medicare Part B once criteria are met. Figures are in the FAQ below.
TMS vs. Spravato®, side by side
| TMS | Spravato® | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | TMS usually takes three to four weeks of daily sessions before a change shows up. | Spravato can work within hours to days for some patients. |
| Visits | TMS means shorter visits but many of them, every weekday. | Twice a week, then weekly, adds up to far fewer trips than daily TMS. |
| Side effects | TMS has milder, shorter-lived effects. | Dissociation, dizziness, nausea, and a temporary rise in blood pressure |
Who May Be a Better Fit for TMS?
Patients Who Prefer to Avoid Dissociative Effects
If a floaty, disconnected feeling sounds unappealing, TMS avoids it entirely.
Patients Who Can Commit to Daily Sessions
A weekday visit for several weeks works best if your schedule has room for it.
Medication-Sensitive or Medication-Free Preferences
TMS involves no drug, which matters if you’ve struggled with side effects or want to avoid adding another medication.
Wondering if this fits your situation?
Our intake team can check your insurance and walk you through the first visit.
Who May Be a Better Fit for Spravato?
Patients Needing Faster Relief
When waiting weeks isn’t realistic, Spravato’s quicker onset can matter.
Patients With Co-Occurring Anxiety or Suicidal Thoughts (Per Clinical Evaluation)
Spravato carries an approval for major depressive disorder with acute suicidal thoughts. Whether it suits you, especially with co-occurring anxiety, is a call for your clinician after an evaluation.
Patients Who Want a Less Time-Intensive Schedule
Twice a week, then weekly, adds up to far fewer trips than daily TMS.
Not sure which fits you? See if you qualify →
Can You Combine TMS and Spravato?
What Research and Clinical Practice Suggest
Research on using both at the same time is limited. Any decision to combine them belongs with your provider, based on your history.
Sequencing Treatments When One Doesn’t Work
A more common path is trying one, then moving to the other if results fall short. A treatment that doesn’t work for you says little about the next one, since they act through different mechanisms.
How to Decide: Questions to Ask Your Provider
Treatment History and Diagnosis
Which treatments have I truly tried, and does anything in my history rule one of these out?
Lifestyle, Transportation, and Schedule
Can I make daily visits for weeks, or arrange a ride home after each Spravato session?
Insurance and Out-of-Pocket Costs
What will my plan cover for each, and who handles prior authorization?
Spravato Care at Marpa Minds
Licensed Clinicians Guiding Every Session
At Marpa Minds
A trained provider stays with you from the first dose through discharge.
A trained provider stays with you from the first dose through discharge. Our Spravato guide walks through what a full course looks like.
A Supportive, Spa-Like Clinical Environment
Marpa Minds built its clinics to feel like a quiet, private space instead of a standard waiting room.
Locations in Westchester and Rockland County

Clinics in White Plains and Rockland County serve patients on both sides of the Hudson.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is TMS or Spravato more effective for treatment-resistant depression?
Neither has been shown to be clearly better in head-to-head research, and results vary by person.
Which works faster, TMS or Spravato?
Spravato can work within hours to days for some patients, while TMS typically takes three to four weeks.
Can I do TMS and Spravato at the same time?
Research on combining them is limited, so this is a decision to make with your provider.
Does insurance cover both TMS and Spravato?
Most major plans and Medicare Part B cover both once prior authorization and criteria are met. Without insurance, TMS often runs $6,000 to $15,000 per course, and Spravato roughly $1,000 to $1,500 or more per session.
Which has fewer side effects, TMS or Spravato?
TMS side effects are typically milder and shorter, though Spravato’s are manageable under supervision.
What if one treatment doesn’t work for me?
Moving to the other is a common next step, since they work through different mechanisms.
This article is for informational purposes and isn’t a substitute for medical advice. Talk with a licensed clinician about which treatment may be appropriate for your specific situation.
Ready to find the treatment that fits you? Get Started Now →
Talk to someone who does this every day.
Our intake team checks your insurance and answers your questions before you decide anything.



